I know the name of these cookies is a mouthful…but I promise it’s a yummy one!
This weekend, after eating as much fried food as two people are capable of taking down in two hours, Dave and I discussed how to make the yummiest cookie ever. His contributions were “bacon, peanut butter and cookie dough.” Classic male thinking. But cookie dough inside the cookie? I thought about that one long and hard and it was making my head hurt, so I ditched that part of the concept. But the peanut butter and bacon made the cut. 🙂
The base cookie is made with vanilla pudding, which makes them fluffy and crumbly instead of flat. It’s my grandmother’s secret recipe (only it’s not secret, it’s published in our family cookbook. But, it’s fun to pretend it’s secret.)
Now it’s even less secret—because, here you go!
Chocolate Chip Pudding Cookies (with peanut butter and bacon)
–2 1/4 C flour
–1 tsp baking soda
–1/2 C margarine
–1/2 C shortening (don’t leave this out and don’t sub butter! The shortening helps with their fluffy texture)
–1/4 C granulated sugar
–3/4 C light brown sugar
–1 pkg vanilla instant pudding (4 oz serving size) (also do not leave out to maintain said fluffiness)
–1 tsp vanilla
–12 oz chocolate chips
–1 C chopped nuts (I left these out this time in lieu of 1/2 C peanut butter AND BACON)
Preheat oven to 375 degrees. Mix flour with baking soda. Combine butter, shortening, sugars, pudding mix and vanilla in large mixer bowl (and 1/2 C peanut butter, if using). Beat until smooth and creamy. Beat in eggs. Gradually add flour, then stir in chips and nuts (and bacon, if using—I recommend 8-10 pieces, cooked and crumbled—go big or go home, right?). Batter will be stiff. Bake at 375 for 8 to 10 minutes. Makes about 7 dozen.
The bacon was a fantastic addition. When Dave mentioned it on Saturday, I said, “You know bacon in cookies is a thing, right? It’s pretty popular right now.” He thought he had invented the bacon-in-cookies concept. Not so, but I can keep working on that cookie-dough-in-the-cookie conundrum.
So does anyone know:
A) How the heck the cookie dough balls don’t bake right along with the cookies (?)
B) A cookie dough recipe without raw egg (?)
Thoughts? I’m determined to create this cookie dough cookie. It will happen. Maybe I’ll even stuff some CHOCOLATE-COVERED BACON in them.
In the meantime, enjoy Chocolate Chip Pudding Cookies With Peanut Butter And Bacon-induced bliss. 🙂
In other news (there was sadly no way to segue gracefully) I stumbled on a movie premier red carpet last night! It was for the new Anna Faris and Chris Evans movie. I’ll share pics later this week!